@loughnane_kevin @HenryKarlsonIII Augustine disagrees with Cyprians point on baptism in On Baptism against the Donatists, which we still do. We don’t rebaptize those baptized by heretics. In the end, my point stands EENS is third century, not “always” as you listed as premise. Without that, your argument fails.

Augustine disagrees with Cyprians point on baptism in On Baptism against the Donatists, which we still do. We don’t rebaptize those baptized by heretics. In the end, my point stands EENS is third century, not “always” as you listed as premise. Without that, your argument fails.

— Michael Rogers, SJ (@mrogerssj) June 22, 2020

from Twitter https://twitter.com/mrogerssj